Movie Review: One for the Money

It was with great trepidation that I went to the theater to see One for the Money, based on the first book in the Stephanie Plum series by Janet Evanovich. I haven’t exactly been circumspect about what I thought of the casting – for Stephanie Plum, Ranger and Morelli. Heck, I even posted my own choices for the main characters. Because I thought the film-makers were completely off target on most of their choices, I hadn’t planned to see the movie.

But then I saw a couple of bloggers, bloggers who enjoyed the books, post that they liked the movie. I decided to keep an open mind and check it out.

To my surprise, I didn’t hate it. Now, before you think I’m giving it a full endorsement, let me say that I didn’t love it, either. There were some things that the film-makers did well, and some that they didn’t. First, the script – the screenwriters did a pretty good job of adapting the book, in spite of a slow beginning. I wasn’t crazy with how it started out – the first dinner scene at Stephanie’s parents’ house was awkward and not funny, and that’s mostly because the casting for Mr. and Mrs. Plum and Grandma Mazur just wasn’t right.

Debbie Reynolds is a fantastic actress, but she is no Grandma Mazur. She’s not nearly old and shriveled enough, and is too va-va-voom. In the book, when Grandma Mazur raves about wanting a thong, it’s funny because you can’t imagine this old, prune-like woman wearing one. When Debbie Reynolds makes the crack, you figure she’s probably already got a couple dozen.

Next, Mr. Plum. I always pictured Kevin Arnold’s dad from The Wonder Years – the strong and silent type who expresses his irritation in grunts and pissed-off expressions. He hardly says a word in the books, and it’s only when he’s been pushed way past his limit. In the film, Mr. Plum complains about Grandma Mazur in a whiny voice – it doesn’t have quite the same effect. Mrs. Plum was okay, but nothing spectacular.

Okay, let’s talk about a few characters they got right: Vinnie, Lula, and Connie. None of these characters make huge appearances in the film, but they all were cast well and I can see how funny they would be in the sequels. Also, Benito Ramirez – the actor who played the boxer-slash-murderer-slash-rapist was very creepy and shudder-inducing.

Now, my apologies to all of you who had held out hope that Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson would play Ranger, but I could never picture him playing the part. Yes, he has the build, but he’s not Latino. Daniel Sunjata was absolutely perfect as Ranger – I hope they make a sequel simply so I can see him in the role again!

My biggest surprise was how much I bought Jason O’Mara as Joe Morelli. I know, I know, O’Mara is so Irish he’s barely lost his accent, and he doesn’t have brown eyes like melted chocolate, but he gets Morelli. The way he carries himself, the way he can switch from completely pissed to turning on the sex appeal, the way he says, “cupcake”…. I actually LOVED him as Morelli. So sue me. ;)

Of course, that just leaves Katherine Heigl as Stephanie Plum. And I still believe that this was a casting mistake on the part of the producers. She wasn’t as horrible as I expected, but she wasn’t Stephanie either. She acted like Stephanie, but she didn’t become Stephanie, if that makes any sense. Her accent came and went – mostly went – until she hit a funny line, and then it was like she was doing a Robert De Niro impression, and not a good one. There were a few scenes where she was good – the scene with Benito Ramirez, the scenes with Lula, and she did have good chemistry with both men. I think she could get better – but, just in case any of the producers are reading my blog looking for advice for a possible sequel – she needs to drop the accent. If she can’t get it, she should just use her own voice and the New Jersey euphemisms – it will sound much more authentic than a really bad accent that comes and goes.

So, there you have it – it wasn’t everything I could have hoped for, but it wasn’t as bad as I expected, either. :)

(One other little nit-picky comment: pronunciation of names. Because I listened to all of the books on audio, I heard names like Kuntz and Mazur pronounced by Lorelei King, narrator extraordinaire, and was bugged when they were pronounced differently in the film.)

This entry was posted in movies and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

16 Responses to Movie Review: One for the Money

  1. Sandy
    Twitter: youvegottaread

    Boy Carrie I’m glad you saw it for me, and reported in. I saw that the Rotten Tomatoes score was in the single digits. That, combined with the fact that I knew there was bad casting for Stephanie, I just couldn’t do it. I have to agree with you, from what I saw, Morelli and Ranger were spot on.
    Sandy´s last post ..The Woman in Black (2012)

    • CarrieK
      Twitter: booksandmovies

      Sandy – I wish that they would recast her and keep going with the series. Oh, and recast the parents and G-ma Mazur. Not gonna happen, though. :(

  2. Alpa says:

    I have been planning to read this series since so long .. I guess after your review I will try movie first.

  3. Sheila (Book Journey)
    Twitter: bookjourney

    I think you read my post when I reviewed it and I enjoyed it… I also claimed that it could be that I was pretty distanced from the books, haven’t read one in hmmmm….. 6 years? I also could have been movie starved… I have not been to a movie since before Thanksgiving and I was due! :)

    • CarrieK
      Twitter: booksandmovies

      Sheila – I admit, I’m a bit fanatical about the series – mainly because I adore the audiobook experience. Not every reader is going to be as picky as me!

  4. bermudaonion (Kathy)
    Twitter: bermudaonion

    I can’t decide if I want to see this one or not.
    bermudaonion (Kathy)´s last post ..Mailbox Monday

  5. Kailana says:

    I wasn’t very interested in seeing this movie, but I am hearing good things about it. That surprised me, to be honest. I am still not sure if I will watch it, but I can always change my mind.
    Kailana´s last post ..Week in Review (5)

  6. Kitty
    Twitter: maynekitty

    I read up to #10 in the Plum series and have 10,11,12 on the shelf. My cousin dared me to read the entire series. I won’t be seeing this for two reasons: 1) filmed in Pittsburgh not Trenton 2) Debbie Reynolds as Grandma Mazur. Debbie Reynolds as Grandma Mazur? Not even close. They chose to film in PA because the NJ legislators began talking of revoking film and television tax credits just around the time Trenton was being considered as a location and thus the production company decided on Pittsburgh. The NJ Assembly was due to vote on reinstating the tax credits in 2nd week of Jan 2012 but it was postponed due to the death of the minority leader, Alex DeCroce. Seemed foolish for NJ to remove the tax credit when most of the surrounding states have a film tax credit.

  7. Kathleen says:

    I’ve only read one of the Stephanie Plum novels but still can’t imagine Katherine Heigel in the role. I’m glad you didn’t hate the movie. There is nothing worse than a movie ruining a favorite book and or literary character.
    Kathleen´s last post ..Bookish Goodness

  8. stacybuckeye says:

    I didn’t think Heigl became Stephanie either. She wasn’t quick enough. Like you, I thought the movie was just okay.
    stacybuckeye´s last post ..Agatha Christie Quiz

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

CommentLuv badge